Why are flavored tobacco and cigarettes banned?
Many studies show the benefits of flavored tobacco and cigarettes bans. For starters, as might be expected, flavor bans have been associated with reduced sales of flavored tobacco products in Europe and North America.[1] If flavored tobacco is not for sale, fewer people buy flavored tobacco.
An analysis of menthol smoking rates in Canada also showed that the ban was associated with more quit attempts and more successful quit attempts among menthol-smokers versus non-menthol smokers. In addition, the study suggested that the absence of menthol tobacco may have prevented the relapse of menthol smokers who quit before the ban was in place.
Studies also highlight areas where bans are falling short. The study of menthol smoking rates in Canada showed that menthol smokers were more likely to switch to non-menthol cigarettes than they were to quit completely.
Similar trends were seen in the U.S. While data suggested the flavor ban, which did not include menthol, reduced smoking rates among youth and young adult smokers, most smokers switched to menthol or non-flavored cigarettes. Five years after the flavor ban, flavored cigar sales had also increased, suggesting that some users were simply switching to other flavored products. In eight EU countries, 9% of surveyed smokers had quit completely after the EU flavor ban, while 5% had moved to menthol cigarettes and 62% had moved to unflavored cigarettes.
The tobacco industry would like you to think that flavored tobacco bans are not effective. But the industry also has a history of promoting misleading science that supports its commercial interests. This proved to be the case in 2021, when the industry touted data which suggested that the city of San Francisco (California)’s flavor ban led to higher smoking rates among high school students. In a subsequent paper, researchers revealed that the data analyzed in the industry-touted study was collected before the ban was enforced.
The positive effects of these flavor bans are promising. But to be more effective in reducing tobacco use, bans should be more comprehensive. Bans should include all flavored tobacco products and new products and product modifications the industry creates to undermine these bans, such as flavor accessories and all flavor additives.
Flavor bans that cover all tobacco products and the marketing of these products could reduce the number of smokers switching from flavored cigarettes to flavored cigars, for example. Banning flavored accessories, such as flavored filter tips, flavor capsules and flavor cards, could also prevent the continued use of flavored products. And banning flavor additives, instead of “characterizing flavors,” would be easier to monitor and prevent undetectable flavors from doing harm. With a more comprehensive ban the industry would have fewer loopholes to exploit.
In addition, introducing or promoting proven quit-smoking services when flavor bans are introduced could reduce the number of flavored-tobacco users who simply switch to non-flavored tobacco.
It’s important to remember what the short-term data available thus far may not be capturing: the number of young people who never started using tobacco (flavored or otherwise) due to these bans. If a key reason to ban flavors is to reduce youth uptake of tobacco, this outcome of the bans cannot be overlooked.